.

Records Reveal Which Monmouth County Campaigns Got Birdsall Donations

A report by The Star-Ledger shows $66,035 went to politicians in Monmouth County.

Employees of Birdsall Services Group made more than $18,150 in secret contributions to Monmouth County Freeholder campaign committees
Employees of Birdsall Services Group made more than $18,150 in secret contributions to Monmouth County Freeholder campaign committees

This post was written by Patch Field Editor Elaine Piniat. Additional writing was contributed by Brick Patch Local Editor Colleen Platt.

An in-depth look at Birdsall Service Group's alleged pay-to-play scandal  examines how some of that money trickled down to area politicians — including the Monmouth County Freeholders and local mayors and committee and council members.

A Star-Ledger article published Sunday notes that Birdsall reimbursed employees with bonuses after the staffers wrote personal checks to area candidates — many of whom are serving in Monmouth County.

Records show $66,035 went to politicians in Monmouth County. Birdsall earned $4.2 million from Monmouth County for engineering work, The Star-Ledger reported.

On Oct. 23, 2008 alone, Birdsall donated $2,700 to the Election Fund of John Curley. The Star-Ledger’s records show that Birdsall made donations ranging from $60 to more than $4,000 over the course of four years to Monmouth County affiliated groups.

The engineering firm also donated to municipal political organizations, both democratic and republican, in Monmouth County. Records show donations made to Atlantic Highlands Democratic Support, Committee to Elect Jim Schatzle and Mike Fitzgerald (Republican, Colts Neck), the Eatontown Democratic Campaign, the Hazlet Republican Club, the Committee to Elect DiMaso and Hinds (Republican, Holmdel), various Board of Education candidates in Howell, the Election Fund of Adam Schneider (Democrat, Long Branch) and many more.

A graph created by The Star-Ledger, breaks down donations made throughout the county and state. On May 31, 2009, $3,000 was donated to the Committee to Elect Ryan D. Green for Manalapan Township Committee (Republican) for a wine and cheese tasting event. On March 27, 2012, $4,000 was donated to Monmouth Democracy for a cocktail reception honoring Marlboro Democratic Municipal Chairman Frank LaRocca.

The Star-Ledger reported that from 2008 to 2012, Birdsall made more than 1,000 secret contributions worth $1.05 million to candidates and political groups across the state. During that time, Birdsall earned more than $84 million in public contracts.

Birdsall gave $3,900 in corporate and individual contributions to Republicans in Holmdel in 2011, during the time a controversial sewer expansion was being debated, the Asbury Park Press found. Birdsall oversaw Holmdel’s sewer services.

Mayor Patrick Impreveduto, a Holmdel Republican whose campaign committee received $1,700 from Birdsall from 2009 to 2011, told the Asbury Park Press that the money did not impact his decision to put off voting on a redevelopment plan for the property that would have restricted expansion of sewer services.

At this time, no politician who received secret contributions from Birdsall have been accused of any crime, The Star-Ledger said. The Star-Ledger interviewed more than a dozen contribution recipients who said they followed the law, did not give Birdsall special treatment and knew nothing of the firm’s reimbursements to its employees.

According to records of monetary contributions made to Freeholder Tom Arnone, of the $62,702 in contributions for the 2010 general election, none came directly from Birdsall.

The Star-Ledger’s records show that $1,000 was donated to the Friends of Golden for Sheriff in February 2011 for a Freeholder Director Rob Clifton, Freeholder Tom Arnone and Sheriff Shaun Golden kickoff event; $500 in May 2012 for a private dinner event for Freeholder Tom Arnone and Sheriff Shaun Golden; $300 in June 2010 to the Friends of Tom Arnone for Freeholder for a first responders, law enforcement and Friends of Golden, Clifton and Arnone event; $500 in May 2012 to the Friends of Tom Arnone for Freeholder for a private dinner event for Freeholder Tom Arnone and Sheriff Shaun Golden.

The same goes for Deputy Director Serena DiMaso. Of the $14,949 in contributions for the 2010 general election, none came from Birdsall. DiMaso served on the Holmdel Township Committee from 2002 through 2011.

The Star-Ledger’s records show that $300 was donated to the Committee to Elect DiMaso and Hinds in October 2011 for a Holmdel GOP Fundraiser and Get Together; $500 went to the Committee to Elect Serena DiMaso in October 2009 for a Holmdel Republican Organization Campaign Fundraiser; $800 in April 2012 to the Election Fund of Serena DiMaso for cocktails and hors d’oeuvres for Freeholder Serena DiMaso, Esq; $480 to Friends of Freeholder Serena DiMaso, Esq. for a Countdown to St. Patrick’s Day event in March 2012.

According to The Star-Ledger’s records, $2,400 was also donated to Gary Rich for Freeholder from May 2011 through March 2012; $6,000 to Friends of Freeholder Lillian G. Burry or Lillian Burry for Freeholder from September 2008 through November 2011; $5,370 to the Election Fund of John Curley or Friends of John Curley for Freeholder from October 2008 through March 2011.

"As elected officials, we fully support and take care to comply with all relevant election and campaign finance laws," a statement from the Monmouth County Republican Headquarters said. 

County officials are aware that Birdsall allegedly engaged in illegal activities to circumvent the campaign finance laws, according to the statement.

"If true, this conduct is unacceptable to all of us," the statement said.

Monmouth County has awarded contracts to Birdsall since 2006. Contracts were also awarded to other engineering companies based on a competitive bidding and evaluation process, according to the statement.

At the time of the Birdsall indictment, Monmouth County had 10 open contracts with the firm in the amount of $1.617 million, spokesperson Laura Kirkpatrick previously said. Some were multiple year contracts and are still open while others expired earlier in 2013. They were each awarded under a competitive bid process, she said.

As of May 31, a couple contracts with Birdsall were still in place, but the county is not awarding any new contracts to the firm, she previously said.

"Prior to the time these allegations were made public, we had no knowledge that any campaign contributions made to us by any company or any group of employees may have violated any state laws or regulations," the statement said. "We support the Attorney General’s efforts to root out corruption in this or any other matter."

Partner Engineering and Science, a California firm, bought Birdsall Services Group for $5.6 million Friday. The firm has offices in Ramsey and Red Bank.

Partner President Joseph Derhake said that contracts would be earned solely on merit and that his firm would make no political donations.

"If we can’t win the work based on merit alone, we don’t want that work,” Derhake said in a news release Friday.

Patricia J June 25, 2013 at 08:09 AM
I don't understand how it's not illegal for a company with a large contract with a town to give donations to political campaigns. Birdsall had something like a 700k contract with holmdel. It makes it look bad for the town committee who accepted their donations, then to flip flop on sewering decisions on the Lucent property after consulting with engineers (assuming some of those engineers were from birdsall) as the mayor was quoted. Not saying there was any impropriety, just saying the system stinks. If a contractor wants to do business with a municipality they should not be allowed to provide any political contributions 5 years before engaging with a town and 5 years after the contract ends. I'd like to see all of the $ given to charity as a symbolic gesture that demonstrates that our politicians don't want anyone's campaign donations which are from improper sources.
Brian Froelich, Freeholder Candidate June 25, 2013 at 10:21 AM
Regarding the above article comments that no donations were made to the Arnone and DiMaso for the 2013 primary, NOT SURPRISING! Birdsall was already under investigation and/or indictment by then. They had ceased their illegal operations long before that.
anonymous June 25, 2013 at 10:32 AM
Wow!!! Looking at the list in the Star-Ledger, Sheriff Shaun Golden received alot of money denoted as "S"---as in "SECRET" campaign contributions. Sheriff Golden also employed a man during his first year as County "acting sheriff," in a fictitious, non-existent position so he can receive a pension and a county salary. What the hell is going on with a man who has taken an oath of office to uphold all the laws of the land???
Brian Froelich, Freeholder Candidate June 25, 2013 at 11:04 AM
Regarding the article saying that no payments went to Arnone for the 2010 general election, it appears that the Star Ledger report differs. According to the Star Ledger report, on 9/28/10 Birdsall Services Group Hosted Monmouth Republican Freeholder Fundraiser and contributed $2700. 0n 9/16/10 Birdsall contributed $250 at a Reception Saluting Freeholder Candidate Tom Arnone. Both donations are listed as being for Arnone. Regarding the article saying that no payments went to DiMaso for the 2010 general election, she was appointed to the Freeholder Board (not elected) in 2012 and was not a Freeholder candidate in 2010. Birdsall did donate to her previous Holmdel municipal elections and to her 2012 (one year term) general election for Freeholder. Robert Clifton was the Republican Freeholder candidate in 2010 and Birdsall did contribute to his campaign.
anonymous June 25, 2013 at 06:17 PM
Mr. Scarano, Weren't you the Republican Municipal Chair of Holmdel??
Thomas Scarano June 25, 2013 at 06:26 PM
Proudly yes and campaign manager for the holmdel campaigns
Thomas Scarano June 26, 2013 at 02:59 PM
Patricia...if you are assuming that Birdsall engineers would have played any part in deciding Holmdels position on sewering Lucent you are completely wrong . Birdsall provided specialized sewer maintenace for Holmdel. A service by the way that when put out to bid a number of years ago, the only bidder was Birdsall. I hope this clears things up for you
Claudine Scozzari June 27, 2013 at 08:01 AM
Thomas - I think Patricia J. was commenting on the overall local system that has gone amok. There has been a lack of respect of the engineering and public works departments at the local level by fire, police, treasurer, clerk, legal, and business administrators, in general in ALL 21 COUNTIES. And, the muni bond underwriters and the auditors have not helped the situation. These SITUATIONS should not be confused with the pay-to-play issue of the professional services firm was the SOLE BIDDER for work in THEIR TERRITORY, which by the way is RESPECTED at the local level. The problems have risen from those people, like business administrators to name a few such as in Ocean Township (Van Pelt) where POLITICS has been blamed for the problems with the professional services contracts. At the local level, there is a fine line of where it is political and where it is local nonsense created by the local legal team.
Joe DiBella June 27, 2013 at 06:33 PM
Mr. Frolich continues to attempt to suggest that something illegal happened here on the part of the recipients. It did not. If employees of Birdsall contributed illegally or if the company did something illegal, so be it. They will be accountable under the law. But to suggest that the recipients could have known this was happening is not the case. As I have noted before, when Mr. Frolich acts with the same outrage towards Democrats as he does towards Republicans on this, then he may be taken seriously. I see where Mayor Booker received dollars from Birdsall -- Mr. Frolich, what do you say about that?
Brian Froelich, Freeholder Candidate June 27, 2013 at 11:04 PM
Mr DiBella continues to argue that Birdsall paid hundreds thousand of dollars in illegal contributions to get contracts from the recipients but "that the recipients could (not) have known this was happening." Does that make any sense at all? Then, after defending (Monmouth Freeholder) Republican actions, he says I should attack (Newark Mayor) Democrat for those same actions. Does that make sense?
Thomas Scarano June 28, 2013 at 02:09 PM
No Mr. Froelich you make no sense at all. You crticize the donations made to Republicans but not those made to Democrats. You also falsely claim these were illegal donations...they were not. The illegality was the company reimbursing the employees for the contribution. I realize you are a candidate with no platform but it does not excuse such false statements
Brian Froelich, Freeholder Candidate June 30, 2013 at 09:49 PM
My characterization is accurate and the same as the Republican NJ Attorney General. “Attorney General Jeffrey S. Chiesa announced that (Birdsall)....conspired in a scheme to avoid the restrictions of New Jersey’s Pay-to-Play Act by disguising illegal corporate political contributions as personal contributions of employees of the firm.” (http://nj.gov/oag/newsreleases13/pr20130326b.html ) The contributions/donations were illegal. Sorry Mr Scarano you can’t defend the people who knowingly gave or took those donations- regardless of party- by trying to attack me.

Boards

More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »